13 Best Baby Crib Mattress of 2023

Babies can sleep much to 17 hours a day; Finding a mattress for their crib that is safe and pleasant is a major priority for parents. Federal standards govern crib mattress measurements and other safety issues, but parents still have a wide choice of products to select.

Understandably, purchasing the best baby crib mattress can be a difficult experience for new parents, given its significance regarding a baby’s safety and sleep pattern.

Many different crib mattresses are available, ranging from classic innerspring and foam designs to dual-sided infant and toddler mattresses. Your specific requirements and financial constraints determine the type you select.

Have no idea where to begin? It’s nothing to be concerned about. We have done the legwork and compiled a list of the best baby crib mattresses currently available, so you can rest easy knowing you’re not worrying about anything else.

Disclaimer: We independently review all recommended products. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. For more details read our Affiliate Disclosure.

Top 13 Best Baby Crib Mattress

1. Twilight Crib and Toddler Mattress- DREAM ON ME
2. Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress
3. Dourxi Crib Mattress
4. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed
5. Best Overall Crib Mattress- Colgate Eco Classica III
6. Best Lightweight Crib Mattress- Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress
7. Naturepedic Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic
8. Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress
9. Best Innerspring Crib Mattress- SEALY
10. Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress
11. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Mattress
12. Best Affordable Eco-Friendly Crib Mattress- Serta
13. Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

1. Twilight Crib and Toddler Mattress- DREAM ON ME

Highlights

• 5″ Twilight Innerspring Crib and Toddler Mattress with 80 Coil Design
• Extra Firm and Support
• Comfort and Safety Assured
• Greenguard Gold Certified
• JPMA Certified
• Brown Clouds

Product Description

This design demonstrates that a crib mattress doesn’t have to cost a fortune if you’re on a budget. It’s a well-liked alternative on Amazon, with over 5,900 positive ratings. Customers like how light it is while still being firm.

You may use it with both infants and toddlers because it has two firmness levels and is reversible.

It also has a waterproof, reinforced cover and binding to fend any spills. Some people have complained about the durability and the noise level of the materials as a drawback.

2. Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress

Highlights

• Waterproof Cover
• Hypoallergenic
• CertiPUR-US Certified

Product Description

Milliard created a foam mattress that replicates the womb’s atmosphere. It’s hypoallergenic and waterproof, so it’ll keep your baby safe from bacteria, mildew, dust mites, and other allergies.

Because the mattress will be delivered wrapped and vacuum packed, it will take 48 hours to inflate to its final size and shape. Pamper This crib mattress has a strong foam scent, according to some parents. The manufacturer suggests leaving it around for a few weeks before using it to get rid of the smell.

3. Dourxi Crib Mattress

Highlights

• Toddler Bed with Two Sides
• Machine-washable
• 3-D Spacer Cover with Breathable Vents
• 2 Stages Foam Crib Mattress
• Sides for Infants and Toddlers
• Firm Foam with a High Density
• Memory Foam with a Cooling Gel Infusion;
• CertiPUR-US Certified

Product Description

We designed our Dourxi dual-sided mattress to accommodate your developing baby. For your baby’s safety, the Infants side is designed to be firmer. The Toddlers side is softer yet still provides support for your growing child’s nighttime movements.

The breathing surface is a three-dimensional divider honeycomb netting fabric comprising 94% air. That enables continual air exchange and high breathability and prevents humidity formation. The blankets help to keep children from being too hot or too cold by keeping them close to a dry, cool surface.

Feel secure in your mattress selection for health and safety. Substance, pollutants, and reliability have all been approved by CertiPUR-US. In addition, they offer a 10-year warranty and top-notch customer service.

4. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Highlights

• Reduces Suffocation Risk Because It Is 100% Breathable
• Washable in a Standard Washing Machine
• Alternative to Organic: Non-Toxic
• It’s possible to remove the cover.
• For babies and toddlers up to 3 years old (2-Stage)
• Thickness: 5.5 in. Color: White
• Made in the USA

Product Description

This hypoallergenic baby mattress has a Woven Aire core comprised of 90% air and 10% food-grade polymer, delivering the same comfort while being more breathable than foam or coils.

It’s the only crib mattress that can be cleaned in the washing machine, but a waterproof cover is also available if you prefer that. The dual-sided construction will last you until your child’s toddler years, and it’s the only crib mattress that can be washed. Greenguard Gold certification is also included.

5. Best Overall Crib Mattress- Colgate Eco Classica III

Highlights

• Dual Firmness
• Organic Waterproof Cotton Cover
• Baby and Toddler Mattress in Two Stages
• Foam that’s Hypoallergenic
• Eco-Friendly Foam
• Greenguard Gold Certified

Product Description

As recommended by experts, the extra firm side is for babies, while the softer, less firm side offers the comfort that toddlers seek during these crucial first years. Complies with CPSIA criteria while meeting or exceeding federal and state requirements for fire resistance.

It has a waterproof backing that is built into the bed to keep the baby’s skin as close to organic cotton as possible as they sleep.

It is made with high-quality fabrics has reversed seams for increased durability, so it will endure your baby’s infant-toddler years, giving him or her a safe, pleasant place to rest and grow.

6. Best Lightweight Crib Mattress- Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress

Highlights

• A White Crib mattress for Infants and Toddlers
• Hypoallergenic
• Lightweight
• Water-Resistant
• 10-year Limited Warranty
• Green Guard Gold Certified

Product Description

According to the manufacturer, the core of this GREENGUARD Gold-certified mattress is made of high-density, thermo-bonded foam. The polyester core serves as a support structure.

A waterproof, stain- and odor-resistant wipe-clean cover is included. In addition to being tearproof, the mattress is built to last.

With a weight of under 8 pounds, the mattress is also quite portable (lb.). However, it is important to keep in mind that it is limited to a weight capacity of 50 lbs.

Also Read: 15 Best Mattress for Kids – An Ultimate Guide

7. Naturepedic Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic

Highlights

• Non-Toxic Baby and Toddler Bed
• Classic Style and Lightweight
• Firm Support
• Natural Waterproof Coating
• Greenguard Certifications

Product Description

The Naturepedic Organic Cotton Lightweight Classic is our top pick for parents looking for a crib mattress that meets the Global Organic Textile Standard after weighing the options (GOTS).

Even though the Naturepedic mattress does not have a second side, it is firm enough and provides the best value for money out of all the natural beds we looked at.

The mattress’s polyethylene core is covered in a layer of organic ingredients cotton batting, then brushed with food-grade waterproof plastic. No conventional fire retardants or barriers are utilized, yet the material meets all US regulatory flammability standards.

Also Greenguard Gold Certified. It’s waterproof, so cleaning up spills and messes isn’t too time-consuming; commonly accessible both online and at leading baby stores, and it comes with a complete warranty.

8. Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress

Highlights

• Baby-Friendly Firmness
• 100% Machine Washable
• Mattress in a Box
• Water-Resistant Cover
• Removable Outside Cover
• Greenguard Gold and CertiPUR Certified

Product Description

In addition to being GREENGUARD Gold Certified, this crib and toddler mattress is CertiPUR-US Certified, which means it is free of ozone-depleting chemicals, mercury, lead, formaldehyde, and other metals.

The 2021 Edition mattress has a soft, detachable, water-resistant protective surface that can be machine washed. Hang to dry after washing in cool water on the gentle cycle without bleach (do not place in the dryer machine).

For the protection of newborns, a stronger foam foundation is advised. JPMA Certified, showing that independent laboratories have reviewed the product to assure the safety of your child; Greenguard Gold certification confirms the product is free of phthalates, lead, and mercury.

To get the most out of your mattress, we recommend that you allow it to expand immediately after delivery in a room-temperature setting.

9. Best Innerspring Crib Mattress- SEALY

Highlights

• Baby Flex Cool
• Dual Firmness
• 204 Premium Coils
• Made in the USA
• Waterproof Mattress for Toddlers and Babies

Product Description

This innerspring choice has 204 coils to provide a firm base on the infant side if you like a more traditional mattress. One side is more cushiony for growing toddlers, while the other has a cotton cover with foam in the center.

The brand claims that the use of vertical metal rods around the borders prevents sagging. Although this mattress generally received positive reviews, several customers complained that the fabric cover wasn’t as washable as other mattresses available.

10. Lullaby Earth Healthy Support Crib Mattress

Highlights

• Waterproof Material
• Dual Firmness
• Lifetime Warranty
• Made in the USA

Product Description

One side of the Lullaby Earth mattress is firm for babies and toddlers, while the other is softer. The Wave support core gives the mattress structure while also reducing its weight, making it easy to swap out the fitted sheet when necessary.

For a snug fit in the crib, the corners are square, and the edges are strengthened. With a moderate detergent and a cloth, you can easily clean the waterproof cover.

This is one of the thickest foam mattresses, coming in at six inches. If you want a dense foam baby mattress, go for one that is thick.

11. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Mattress

Highlights

• Recycled Fiber Core with a Premium Double-Sided Surface
• Crib and Toddler Mattress
• Waterproof and Lightweight
• Natural/Non-Toxic
• Size: 27.5″ wide by 52″ long by a few inches high
• Greenguard Gold Certified
• 7 Year Warranty
• Made in the USA.

Product Description

A non-toxic building has been constructed without the use of poisonous materials or chemicals. With a strong fiber core, babies and toddlers can rest easily.

The vinyl used for the cover is long-lasting and weatherproof, and it requires little maintenance. Transform the mattress into a waterproof cover when the child is willing to move to a toddler bed.

Products that are Greenguard Gold certified have low chemical emissions and help to create healthier surroundings. Toxic fire retardants are not used in this product because it meets or exceeds all applicable safety testing requirements for these substances.

The manufacturer offers a 7-year limited guarantee with the mattress. Produced in the United States of America. With the lightweight design, it’s simple to switch the sheets. The crib or toddler bed’s square corners aid in a solid fit inside the structure.

12. Best Affordable Eco-Friendly Crib Mattress- Serta

Highlights

• Dual Sided Premium Crib and Toddler Mattress
• Recycled Fiber Core
• Greenguard Gold Certification (Non-Toxic)
• Trusted 7-Year Warranty
• Made in the United States of America

Product Description

It is Greenguard Gold Certified, so you can rest easy knowing it’s constructed with eco-friendly components. You can wipe it clean after an unexpected blowout in the middle of the night because it features a waterproof vinyl cover.

Because it’s customized to fit in any regular crib perfectly, it’s also firm enough to keep the baby secure.

13. Kolcraft Pure Sleep Therapeutic Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

Highlights

• 150 Extra Firm Coils
• Firm Support
• Waterproof and Breathable
• Greenguard Gold certified
• Made in the USA
• 10-year Warranty

Product Description

As your infant grows, the 150 thick gauge steel coils provide sturdy support. For the best possible sleep, use a firm, non-allergenic sleeping surface.

Lock-stitched waterproof binding and waterproof cover keep out stains and moisture. For a hygienic sleeping surface, simply dampen a cloth and wipe the entire mattress down. A damp cloth is all that’s needed to clean the Perma-Dri cover.

This mattress is Greenguard Gold certified for indoor environmental quality and chemical stability emissions to provide your infant with a healthier sleeping environment.

Toxic fire retardants are completely absent from the mattress, which complies with phthalate and flammability regulations.

Produced in the United States, with a craftsmanship and material warranty of ten years. Supports both USA standard-sized cribs and toddler beds, measuring 51.63″ long by 27.25″ wide by 5″ high.

What Are the Types of Crib Mattress?

The most important thing to remember when purchasing a crib mattress is to pick a high-quality one. It’s a matter of personal choice as to the type you choose to purchase. The following are your choices:

Innerspring Mattresses

Steel-coil innerspring give this conventional mattress its resilience and sturdiness. Polyester, cotton, and foam are common cushioning materials found above the coils of an innerspring mattress.

Concerning innerspring mattresses, coil count (the number of steel springs in the bed) and steel gauge are terms you’ll find used to describe them. Metal border rods are also available, which add additional durability around the corners.

High-coil-count innerspring mattresses, in particular, can be expensive. The price range for reputable brands is between $80 and $300. In addition, these mattresses are heavier.

Foam Mattresses

The most common material used to create them is polyurethane foam resin. Foam mattresses are a good alternative because of their lightweight, durability, and low cost.

When purchasing a foam crib mattress, look for one that is both comfortable and long-lasting. Put your palm on the bed and time how long it takes for it to recover its structure (the faster, the better).

A firmer mattress will have a higher density, so look for that as well. Denser mattresses tend to be heavier, but you can squeeze the sides of a softer mattress to see if it holds up under pressure.

Double-Sided Mattresses

Mattresses for infants have a firmer side, whereas toddlers who are still using a crib or a toddler bed have a softer side. Turn it over to provide your child with a smoother, more pleasant sleeping surface on the other side.

Be aware that these mattresses may be more costly than other options for baby cribs. When changing the crib sheets, make sure to place the right side of the bed on top.

How to Choose a Best Crib Mattress

There are a few key differences between crib mattresses and adult mattresses. When shopping for a crib mattress, look for the following features:

Firmness

In addition to keeping babies secure and supporting their growing bones as they sleep, crib mattresses are stiffer than those for adults. Check to see if the bed is safe for babies to sleep on.

Waterproof

A vinyl or polyethylene cover should be used on crib mattresses to keep moisture out and mildew from forming on them. Use something impermeable to cover anything made of fabric.

Fit

It’s critical that the mattress and frame fit snugly together. There should be no more than two fingers’ width of space between the crib and the bed. A little crib or bassinet will have the same sizing requirements as a crib.

Materials

Chemicals used in mattress production are an issue for some parents, who choose mattresses made of natural or organic materials instead. (Note: There has been no research done on the potential health implications.)

Crib Mattress Safety Guidelines

The safety of your child is of the utmost importance. When picking a crib mattress, remember these safety considerations:

Avoid Second-Hand If Possible

Mold and germs present in used mattresses provide a serious health risk. Therefore, it’s recommended to stay away from them if you don’t know anything about them.

Don’t you dare use something from another of your child! Check the waterproof cover to make sure there aren’t any cracks or gaps where mold can grow.

Keep the Crib Empty

However, despite the fact that cushions, protectors, plush toys, and blankets look adorable in a child’s room, they are not permitted in their cribs. It’s possible that they’ll suffocate your child if they accidentally cover their face with their hands. Please, just give me a fitted sheet.

Place Baby on their Back

Your infant should sleep on their back because it is the safest position for them. Because of this, SIDS, the most prevalent cause of newborn death during the first year of existence, is less likely to occur.

Consult your pediatrician before flipping the mattress: If you’ve got a double-sided mattress, ask if it’s time to switch to the toddler side. Around the age of 12 months, most parents decide to convert to cloth diapers for their infants.

Final Verdict

It’s up to you, Mom and Dad, to pick the best crib mattress for your child. Take A different view about this compiled list of the 13 Best Crib Mattresses to assist you in making an educated choice.

Reviewing our criteria for a crib mattress, here are a few things we check for. You must be confident that your purchase satisfies safety regulations and requirements, just like anything else you buy for your infant.

Perhaps you’re a fan of natural products or products that are good for the environment. Regardless of your preference, you want to get a crib mattress that can provide your child with a chemical-free sleep surface that is breathable.

Extra firm mattresses are best for babies. Softer support is acceptable for toddlers. As your child grows, you may want to consider a mattress with two stages. If you’re going to use a mattress cover, you’ll need to decide the mattress itself is waterproof or not.

Finally, check to see if it fits properly in your crib so that your baby may sleep well at night in a secure environment.